Nick & Elena's Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Overland, Missouri, Nick & Elena's Pizzeria is a cherished destination for lovers of authentic St. Louis-style pizza and hearty Italian-American fare. This cozy neighborhood eatery draws locals and visitors alike with its inviting atmosphere that feels like stepping into a warm, nostalgic embrace—where every meal is a comforting experience and every visit feels like catching up with old friends.

At the core of Nick & Elena’s appeal is their masterful St. Louis-style pizza, known for its ultra-thin, crispy crust that crackles delightfully with each bite. The signature creamy volcanic cheese blankets the pie, delivering an indulgent, gooey texture that pairs perfectly with a diverse array of toppings. Guests rave about the Nick & Elena’s Pizza Supreme and the fan-favorite Sausage Pepperoni Pizza, each slice bursting with vibrant flavors and expertly balanced seasoning. For a lighter touch, the refreshing House Salad or Dinner Salad provide a crisp contrast, while side staples like golden Mozzarella Sticks and Toasted Cannelloni add an extra layer of satisfaction.

But the pizzeria is far more than just pizza. Whether you’re craving the savory richness of Nick’s Special Pasta or the crispy, flavorful bite of their New York Style Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza, the menu truly offers something to satisfy every appetite. Sandwich lovers can indulge in hearty options like the Italian Hamburger — a half-pound of specially seasoned chopped sirloin on a French roll — or the classic hot roast beef sandwich. And for those seeking a sweet ending, their homemade cannoli is a perfect decadent finish.

The dining experience at Nick & Elena’s is enhanced by attentive staff who genuinely care about your meal, as reflected in glowing praise from customers. Many have noted the restaurant's warm, inviting vibe and community spirit, with one happy guest describing it as “the best pizzeria in STL” and another highlighting how the staff thoughtfully offered complimentary dessert during an extended wait. The lively yet relaxed setting makes it ideal for a casual date night or a family gathering, complete with the best pellet ice to keep your Blue Moon with orange slices perfectly chilled.

Throughout their visit, diners appreciate the attention to detail—from the crisp Crinkle Cut French Fries to the savory Arancini served with marinara sauce—and the richness of homemade flavors that elevate each dish. It’s no surprise that parking lot overflow and packed tables often signal the local passion for this beloved spot. Nick & Elena’s Pizzeria is not just a meal; it’s a heartfelt chapter in St. Louis’s culinary story, inviting you to make your own delicious memories.

If you seek authentic, well-crafted St. Louis pizza in a place where the hospitality and food equally shine, Nick & Elena's is a must-visit. Their commitment to quality and community make each bite feel like home.